All characters
Stranger
Andrew McAllister
Voiced by Jim Conroy
Andrew McAllister is a stranger character in RDR1. Voiced by Jim Conroy. Mission relationships: 0.
- Role
- Strangers
- Voice actor
- Jim Conroy
Trivia
- โEven if the player hogties Evans, McAllister will notice blood on the deed.
- โThe player can kill McAllister after the mission to re-acquire the deed to Pleasance House, which will then remain a safehouse.
- โIf the player completes this mission after the final story mission "The Last Enemy That Shall Be Destroyed", McAllister will ask, "Is you the man Marston sent with the deed?"
- โMcAllister's actor Jim Conroy also portrayed "Butch" the Republican Space Ranger, from Rockstar Games's Grand Theft Auto IV and Grand Theft Auto V.
Source โ
Last verified October 3, 2026